Terranigma

SNES review by Marc Golding on 25th October 2004

Soulblazer started it all, and did so in fine fashion. That game was simplistic — even by action-RPG standards — but boasted a touching, charming philosophy involving saving souls (of trees, cats and humans alike) so that they could aid you on your quest to stop the greed-blinded king who traded their souls away for good coin in the first place. Enix/Quintet tried to go a whole lot deeper with their Illusion of Gaia, Soulblazer’s follow-up, and the results varied. The charm was still there shining brightly enough, but the attempt at increasing the game’s scope mostly just muddied the mix.

And finally, there is Terranigma, which tries to go even deeper still with its ponderous story featuring reviving continents and such, but Quintet has finally gone so deep as to have buried their game playing audience in heaps of suffocating apathy. Similarly, you could think of Illusion of Gaia’s very unofficial sequel as a sluggish action game buried under heaps of overly dramatic muck.

Terranigma is a bore. There are no two ways about it. Any typically cutesy charm, any simple fun, have been undermined by the title’s illusions of grandeur — it spends so much time trying to manifest a slow build that it just feels slow. Who wants to spend their first two hours or so with an action-RPG slashing at potato bugs and little plants? We are continually assured that greatness is on its way, but the lead up is so tedious that we soon become indifferent as to the possibility of its arrival.

On the bright side, Terranigma boasts a crisp graphic appeal, with tunes alternating between melancholic and majestic. Certainly scenes depicting world restoration when holding hands with the well composed score can give you tiny shivers and suggest that the promise of greatness is not an empty one — but when the uninteresting gameplay rears its head again, you’ll be plunged newly into tedious slashing and leaping about and you’ll want it all to end as soon as possible.

Why does a game with such a pretty pedigree fail so miserably? It’s almost as if there is about two hours of great gaming here, indeed a single chapter’s worth, and that Quintet saw fit to stretch that ill-advisedly out, portioning out the good stuff so stingily, so reluctantly, that the good stuff doesn’t even seem good. A critical eye will still discern the quality elements, but the average gamer likely won’t bother to delve that deep or be that positive. If that’s you, you’re more likely to pick up the game expecting excellence, only to receive instead a sort of weak, watered down, would-be masterwork that will elicit commentary like ”when does it get good, it all seems so promising”. And then you’ll pick up something else, something more worthy of your time. Something like Soulblazer.

Four out of ten

Spread the word

About the author

Marc Golding is a Staff Writer at Thunderbolt, having joined in September 2003.

Comments

  • Dennis

    4th September 2008

    Gravatar

    Okay.. you have NO idea! This game is one of the best I've ever played, the story is deep, the gameplay is fantastic and the music just fits perfect.
    I would give this a 9 out of 10.

    Sure it sn't perfect but you will remember this game! And you will remmber it as an awesome game, trust me.

  • Vinz

    5th September 2008

    Gravatar

    somewhere, in this world, the quintet's members are crying…

    as a my friend spoke in the review of The witcher: "Come on…stop to try to be reviewers."
    he's really damn right!

  • Federico

    18th December 2008

    Gravatar

    Wow, talking about bad calls…

  • Magus

    19th December 2008

    Gravatar

    I'm sorry, but this review is just proposturous. Terranigma may not be a perfect game, but it deserves MUCH more than a 4 out of 10. Frankly, judging by this review I would assume you didn't even finish the game.

    And please don't continuously use the excuse that it's "slow" and "boring", because if majority opinion is any indication, those are highly opinionated factors that this review has put far too much weight into.

  • Anthony Karge

    19th December 2008

    Gravatar

    Personally, I have no tolerance for opinionated factors in reviews. Opinions=lies and misconceptions. I just want the facts without that other stuff.

    And the music in this game is pretty cool.

  • Chinster

    19th December 2008

    Gravatar

    I hope the reviewer was taken out the back and shot after this was posted.

  • Tohofuhai

    19th December 2008

    Gravatar

    I don't mean any disrespect to the reviewer, but I have to agree with a few of the comments. This review seems to consist of two main arguments. First, this game didn't live up to the reviewers expectations. Second, the reviewer found it boring. These factors are, as stated already, highly opinionated and should not be the basis for the entire review. The actual gameplay, the music, and even the story were completely ignored. There's no excuse for this kind of bias in a professional review. And for the record, claiming Soul Blazer to be a good game while harshly bashing Terranigma is a bit hypocritical.

  • Tohofuhai

    19th December 2008

    Gravatar

    Sorry for double commenting, but the reviewer did cover the musical score. My apologies for the mistake.

  • zach k

    22nd May 2009

    Gravatar

    dude, you don’t know crap. this game is fricken sick to the max. one of the top three games i’ve ever played. it’s what got me addicted to rpg’s. great game 10/10 in my book.

  • Camilo

    27th May 2009

    Gravatar

    Why?I really mean why is this review still on-line?
    I have to agree that the first 2 hours are a bit lame but as soon as the civilization part starts…..This game really gets fantastic. fantastic enough for me to give this game a 9,6

  • dreihundert

    3rd June 2009

    Gravatar

    omfg this is one of the best games in history and you give it 4/10 points omg your really job is a room cleaner !!!

  • APepper

    18th June 2009

    Gravatar

    Wow O.O
    How could dare put this score in one of the best games of all time.

    My god you must be a person with a terrible taste or blond.

  • Keeb

    14th September 2009

    Gravatar

    What? Really? I am only 2 hours into the game and I already love it, much less can I imagine that the late game content being worse…

    Let me guess, the writer only buys systems to have the newest “Madden” title? Put down the paddle and just walk away please.

Show the ten other comments

Due to the age of this article, comments are now closed

You may also enjoy